Bears vs. Commanders: Caleb Williams Shows Growth, Officiating Sparks Controversy Season 2 Episode 12

 

By Shawn Mackey | The Shawn Mackey Show

The Chicago Bears pulled off another nail-biter, edging the Washington Commanders 25–24 thanks to a last-second Jake Moody field goal. Déjà vu? It’s the exact same score the Bears used to beat the Raiders earlier this season. But while the scoreboard might feel familiar, the story behind it tells a lot about progress, resilience — and questionable officiating.

Caleb Williams: Early Promise, Late Poise

Caleb Williams started strong, showing command in the pocket early on. Despite some shaky moments and a few too-hot short passes, the rookie kept his cool when it mattered most — leading the Bears downfield for the game-winning kick.

Stat line?

  • 17 of 29 passing for 252 yards

  • 2 total touchdowns (one rushing)

Compare that to Commanders QB Jayden Daniels — 19 of 26 for 263 yards, three touchdowns, and one interception — and it’s clear both young stars are making their cases as future franchise cornerstones. Still, the numbers tell only half the story.

Even with a few missed throws and a controversial officiating night, Williams is progressing. And the comparison that surfaced this week — his first 22 career games versus Troy Aikman’s — shows he’s on the right path. Williams’ 4,720 yards, 29 TDs, and just 8 interceptions far outpace Aikman’s early stats. If that’s any indicator, Bears fans should feel optimistic.

DeAndre Swift: The Offensive Engine

If anyone stole the show, it was DeAndre Swift.

  • 14 carries for 108 yards (7.7 avg)

  • 67 receiving yards and a touchdown

This was easily Swift’s best rushing performance as a Bear. Behind an improving offensive line — anchored by Darnell Wright and Theo Benedett — the Bears churned out 145 total rushing yards. Even backup Roschon Johnson chipped in on special teams while working back from injury.

The “Greats and Ain’ts” of Week 12

Every week, I break down my “Greats and Ain’ts” — the players who shined and those who need a reset.

Greats

  • DeAndre Swift – Explosive and reliable, the Bears’ offensive MVP.

  • Darnell Wright – Tough and consistent, even with that bulky elbow brace.

  • Luther Burden III – Four catches for 51 yards, showing he’s ready for a bigger role.

  • Scott Daly (Long Snapper) – The unsung hero who helped set up the game-winning kick.

  • Devin Duvernay – 120 yards on kick returns; just one block away from breaking one.

Ain’ts

  • Kyler Gordon – Rusty return; gave up key plays in coverage.

  • Naishon Wright – Costly penalties and missed opportunities on defense.

Officiating Woes Continue

Let’s talk about the elephant in the room — the officiating. A phantom illegal formation penalty on Theo Benedett wiped out a stunning Rome Odunze touchdown, even as analysts like Troy Aikman and the broadcast ref both called it a clean play. Add in the questionable OPI on Colston Loveland, and it’s no wonder fans were heated.

And this isn’t just a Bears problem. That recent UTEP study alleging bias in officiating toward certain playoff teams — particularly the Chiefs — may not be gospel, but it reflects growing fan frustration. When officiating affects outcomes, it’s a league-wide issue.

College Corner: The NCAA Poll Problem

The NCAA Top 25 is a weekly exercise in chaos. As I said on the show, the AP Poll is looking more like a guessing game than a ranking system. For example:

  • Two-loss Notre Dame sits at No. 13 after losing to No. 2 Miami and No. 4 Texas A&M.

  • Meanwhile, two-loss Illinois (to No. 1 Ohio State and No. 3 Indiana) drops completely out of the AP rankings.

How does that make sense? It doesn’t. That’s why I’m leaning more toward the AFCA Coaches Poll — the folks with boots on the ground. The coaches’ rankings seem to reflect reality a little better.

Looking Ahead: Bears vs. Saints

The Bears are set to face the 1–5 New Orleans Saints next week — and I’ll be broadcasting from a new location for that episode. Expect some format tweaks and, hopefully, a fourth straight win. If the O-line keeps improving and Caleb Williams keeps maturing, this team might be turning the corner.

Bear down, Chicago.
 Peace — I’m out like Sprout.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Breaking Down the Chicago Bears: Key Lessons from a Tough Season Finale

Image
 The Chicago Bears faced a challenging season finale against the Detroit Lions, leaving fans with mixed emotions and plenty to discuss. In this blog post, we will analyze the game and draw valuable lessons that can impact the Bears' future performance.  1. The Game Overview   The Bears’ season finale against the Lions was nothing short of a roller coaster. The game was marked by a series of ups and downs, culminating in a heartbreaking loss. Shawn Mackey, the podcast host, reflected on the game’s events, highlighting the Bears’ offensive struggles and defensive lapses that ultimately led to their defeat.  2. Offensive Struggles   One of the key takeaways from the game was the Bears' inability to capitalize on opportunities. In the fourth quarter, despite a valiant effort to tie the game, the Bears could not secure a field goal range, managing only three plays and five yards before punting. Mackey questioned the decision-making in that crucial moment, s...
Read more

The Chicago Bears: A Rollercoaster Season and What Lies Ahead S. 2 Ep 23

Image
Introduction: In the latest episode of our podcast, we dive deep into the exhilarating highs and frustrating lows of the Chicago Bears' current season. As the team nears the end of the regular season, fans are left with a mix of hope and anxiety about the future. Join us as we explore the crucial moments that defined their journey and what they need to focus on moving forward. **The Bears vs. Packers Rivalry**   This season, the Bears faced off against their arch-rivals, the Green Bay Packers, not once but three times. With two victories under their belt, the Bears have shown resilience, particularly in their recent match where they outscored the Packers 25-6 in the fourth quarter. Shawn Mackey emphasized the significance of this win, particularly after the Bears' struggling start. "Thank goodness, because Ben Johnson's words could have come back to bite him in the ass," he noted, highlighting the intensity of the rivalry. **Ben Johnson's Bold Statements**   A...
Read more

Super Bowl Recap & Chicago Bears Legends: Building Toward Season 3 of The Shawn Mackey Show

Image
  Season 2, Episode 25 marked the final episode of the season—and it delivered a mix of Super Bowl analysis, Chicago Bears history, and big announcements for Season 3 . From breaking down championship football strategy to honoring iconic Bears players who shaped a generation, this episode blended modern NFL insight with old-school defensive grit. As the show transitions into a more video-focused format, the future promises deeper analysis, graphics breakdowns, and even a Cubs vs. Cardinals rivalry segment with a new contributor. Let’s break it all down. This year’s Super Bowl reinforced a timeless football formula: Elite defense Ball control offense Minimize turnovers Take the points Seattle’s defense proved dominant, applying consistent pressure and forcing critical mistakes. While the opposing quarterback showed flashes, inconsistency and turnovers proved costly. On the other side, the offense stuck to fundamentals—run the ball, control possession, and capitalize ...
Read more